Lord of the Flies: Can Someone Be Innately Evil or Innately Good? Essay

The difference in the appearance humans perceive things is part of the complexity of mankind. What is thought of as crime to one someone sack up be seen as good to a nonher, and vice versa. The issue of good and bad is brought up in William Goldings Lord of the wing, when innocent boys argon set on an island to bear the weight of corporation on their backs. What happens to them? How do past submits effect them? Are their actions good or worthless? The actions of the boys were non a liaison of being good or evil, besides were actions for survival. A mans environment does not influence him towards good or evil, nor is he born with it inside.Man has instincts and inner drives that argon not matters of good and evil, only when of survival. universe atomic number 18 always, by inhering instinct, going to do what is best for them and their survival. Animals, much alike men, obscure when in need. For instance, when they feel they be plunk for into a corner, they will att ack, and when they need food, they will kill to eat. In Lord of the Flies, Ralph was being hunted by son of a bitchs tribe, and in a desperate act in his defense, he thrust his spear through a crack at the inspecting savages. Ralph attacked someone of his have kind for his own survival.It can be believed that man is the derivative of others animals, and as such, they have certain instincts that were instilled from birth. The boys on the island later began to resemble the behavior of animals. At once the crowd surged after it, poured down the rock, leapt on to the woman chaser, screamed, struck, bit, tore. at that place were no words, and no movements but the tearing of teeth and claws (153). William Goldings description of this scene leads a contributor to believe that these boys took on animal like qualities. What kind of human tears with teeth and claws?The boys mistake Simon for their beast and result in ruthlessly killing him. In their state of mind of savagery and hunting , they saw themselves in danger of this beast and their first instinct was to kill eachthing in sight that had the possibility of being it. Humans and animals have a natural instinct to protect themselves in the face of danger, like attacking when backed into a corner. Instincts are innate, but indefinite characteristics such as good or evil are not. The significance of moral values does not apply to actions in a situation for survival.Instincts are not about being good or evil, because the issue of being good and evil is undefined. Whether an action or situation is good or evil depends on who it is and how it is being perceived. This makes this issue uncertain due to the way it is viewed from person to person. Since the way it is seen will differ, man cannot be exclusively evil or exclusively good. select the following example A dog constantly jumps on the window of a door in an attempt to get the attention of the family inside. He is doing this in hopes to be let back inside the house. individual inside the house could view this as being evil, which would be different from the view of an animal lover. They would not consider this evil and would claim that the dog had not caused physical harm and just didnt accredit any better. The dog doesnt believe that it is evil because he is only obeying environmental stimuli. Hes been inside before and knows that it is much nicer than outside, and wants the attention that is inside. The dog has tried to jump on the door before, and had authorized the attention of someone who thus let him in.This leads the dog to believe that what he is doing is the right thing to do. by and by all, he just wants in, right? So the dog is evil because someone inside says he is, but then he is not evil because he doesnt think he is. The opinions on what is evil and what isnt disagree with each other because of how it was perceived by each side. In Lord of the Flies in that location is a situation that deals with Piggys render, which is the key to fire on the island. The glasses are stolen in the middle of the night that leads to a brawl in the dark among the boys.Of course the fact that the glasses were stolen, and that they were Piggys only seeing aid, can be seen as evil, but what about Jacks side? Jack acts upon his need for fire to cook the pig he slaughtered with his tribe to richly enjoy their prize. Ralph and Samneric engage in a fight with whoever they can touch first, not even attempting to reason. Which is evil in this situation? Humans are simply complex animals that respond to complex stimuli, and their behaviors are influenced or are a product of everything that they learn starting from the day of their birth do the day of their death. parliamentary law sets a mold for the good and bad conditions that humans are learning from day to day. The role of troupe in being good or evil is that it acts as this guideline for that long lived dream of acceptance. Its where whats good gets you in, and whats evil is what will make you repulsive. The ideas of power and the abuse of that power are not learned from the environment. The environment is used as a resource to abuse that power. Jack manipulates the boys into get together his tribe and sets up his territory on the island.He threatens people to join his tribe, and hunts those that refuse to. Jacks tactics are an example of how he abuses power by using the environment and how he sets the golf-club guidelines of acceptance. A society could not exist where people are brought up to know what they define as right or wrong, and could stick to that without problem. We decide things. But they dont get done(79). On the island, the civilized rules of having drinking water, shelters, and having a spot for a lavatory are not followed.The boys were brought up having rules like these, but they did not stick to them due to the problem that they didnt have a strong seemly authority figure to instill them. Society acts as this needed component to life, and if its not there then it needs to be made. The creation of society begins with people who have the power to set the rules of acceptance, and they are the ones who establish what is good and what is evil. Society may manipulate others into believing what is good and evil, but those that manipulate society create that belief.Its not that man is innately good or innately evil, its their natural instinct that drives them to do those evil or good deeds based upon what society leads them believe. Man can not be exclusively good or evil because the state of good and evil is undefined. wad are born with an instinct that drives them to do what is necessary in extreme measures. This instinct over takes any other preceding thought and becomes the need for survival. In Lord of the Flies, it wasnt whether or not the inhabitants were evil or good, it was their human reaction and instinct in the case of survival.